How House Autopsy Thinks

Why it works the way it does, and the rules it never bends.

Every deal is scored by the same published rules. We don't adjust results deal by deal, and we don't hide uncertainty behind a clean-looking number.

A price, not just a score

The question in front of you is what to offer. A score at the asking price can't answer it: a MAYBE at the asking price can be a clear BUY a little lower. So we lead with the BUY threshold, the highest price where the deal still scores a BUY, and show how far the asking price is from it. The score is still there; it's the reason the price is where it is.

Five checks, because rentals fail in five different ways

A deal can lose money every month (cash flow), fail to cover its loan (debt safety), cost too much for what the area rents for (market strength), hide a problem in the house itself (property risk), or have no cushion built in (deal structure). One number can't see all five, so each is scored on its own, weighted, and shown to you separately. Every weight and cutoff is published.

Some risks can't be averaged away

An average is generous: strong cash flow can paper over a cracked foundation. For the risks where that would be dangerous, a rule caps the verdict no matter how good the rest looks. Those rules are listed below.

The sample deal, as the app shows it

The same result card and evidence list the app shows, for the sample deal on the homepage. Nothing here is redrawn for this page.

Sample deal · BUY threshold
$227,191
The highest price our score still rates a BUY, with your other numbers unchanged.
MAYBEat the $255,000 asking price · 6.9 / 10

On your numbers it cash flows $429 a month, but the rent isn't checked and two big systems are near the end of their life. Our score rates it a BUY at $227,191 or less.

Asking, $27,809 over
$255,000
BUY at or under
$227,191

Directional analysis from House Autopsy's scoring method, applied to the numbers you entered. Not financial or legal advice. How the score works

Why it's a MAYBE
  • Watch
    The rent is an online estimate.If real rent is 10% lower, this MAYBE becomes a SKIP ($215 / mo cash flow).
  • Watch
    Roof (21 years) and HVAC (17 years) are aging together.About $12,000–$23,000 in likely replacements within 3–5 years.
  • Watch
    Minor foundation concerns.Typical repair range $2,000–$10,000.

The rules that cap a verdict

Five conditions cap the verdict at CAUTION, regardless of how strong the other checks are — the math can't out-vote them. Only the last one can be set aside, and only when you say why:

Severe or moderate foundation concerns
A very-high crime rating
A BRRRR refinance that doesn't recover your capital at standard terms (75% LTV, 3% closing costs)
A DSCR loan with coverage between 1.0× and 1.25× — DSCR loans typically require at least 1.25× to qualify
Cash flow at or below −$300/unit/month — caps the verdict by default; you can acknowledge and proceed past it if you have a specific reason (e.g. a house hack you're subsidizing intentionally), which is the only condition on this list you can override

Two more conditions don't force a lower verdict but attach a note instead — slightly negative cash flow, and DSCR below 1.0× on any loan — because by then the weighted score is already low enough to reflect it. Full detail on all seven is on how the score works.

The principles behind it

Trust over sophistication

A simpler tool investors trust beats a more sophisticated one they don't. When the two pull apart, we choose the one we can explain.

Show the reasoning

You can always see why a deal got its result, and you're allowed to disagree with the verdict while still trusting the math behind it.

Make you a better investor

We show the reasoning, the trade-offs and what to check, not just a conclusion, so you learn to spot it yourself.

Say when we're not sure

Real estate outcomes can't be predicted. Confidence notes, the stress test and the check-before-you-offer list exist to flag when a result stands on thin ground, such as rent from an online estimate.

Risks before features

Our first job is telling you what could go wrong before you commit. When surfacing a risk competes with something flashier, the risk wins.

What we won't do

Let a strong average out-vote a dealbreaker. Foundation, crime, refinance viability, cash flow and debt coverage each cap the verdict once they cross a set line (see above).
Pass off our estimates as market data. Every market's rent-to-price and cap-rate targets say plainly that they're House Autopsy's own planning estimates, and when they were last reviewed.
Let an unverified risk hide behind a confident result. Short-term-rental legality, HOA rental restrictions and state-specific tax or insurance exposure have to be confirmed before a result reads as High confidence.

Learn more